Lack Of Independence Of INEC, Undermining Nigeria”s Elections, Says Osigwe.

A former President of the Nigerian Bar Association (NBA), Mazi Afam Osigwe (SAN) has warned that the lack of independence of the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), weak electoral laws and difficult evidentiary rules are undermining Nigeria’s elections.

The immediate past President of NBA gave the warning on Thursday at the 22nd All Nigeria Editors’ Conference of the Nigerian Guild of Editors (NGE) in Enugu, with the theme: “The Ballot, The Media and the Task Of Keeping Democracy Alive.”

Osigwe , who spoke on “Election Petition in the Digital Age: Independence, Evidence, BVAS,” stressed that the courts had increasingly become involved in determining electoral outcomes, raising questions about whether elections were being decided by voters or judges.

While describing the development as the “judicialisation of the electoral process”, blaming it partly on the difficulty of proving electoral malpractice, Osigwe said Nigeria had one of the highest numbers of election petitions because courts were frequently called upon to determine who won elections.

He said, “The courts have gradually and increasingly usurped the role of the voters in determining the representatives of the people. And I couldn’t have agreed with him more.”

He also queried the effectiveness of the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) and the INEC Result Viewing Portal (IReV), saying technologies introduced to strengthen elections had created fresh legal and evidentiary challenges.

He pointed out that petitioners challenging a state-wide election could be required to produce BVAS devices from every polling unit, despite the limited time allowed for election petitions.

“So if you’re challenging state-wide election, and an issue concerns BVAS from every polling unit, you must physically go and carry the BVAS from every polling unit. And yet the court is not a bit hesitant to set time limits,” he said.

The former NBA president added that the situation defeated the purpose of using technology to make elections and election disputes easier to resolve.

Osigwe also criticised the treatment of evidence obtained through subpoenas, particularly in petitions arising from the 2023 general elections, adding that  petitioners were required to file their evidence within 21 days, making documents or testimony obtained later through subpoenas inadmissible.

He explained that the interpretation had weakened the usefulness of subpoenas, especially where petitioners needed documents in the custody of INEC or other public institutions.

Speaking further on IReV,  he stated that the portal should be given greater evidentiary recognition, even if it was not treated as the primary evidence of an election.

“I’m not saying it should be the primary evidence, but first of all, some recognition should be given to it,” he said.

He expressed concern over a proposed change to the electoral framework which, according to him, would prevent non-compliance with INEC regulations and guidelines from constituting grounds for challenging an election.

Osigwe warned that such a provision could encourage politicians to focus only on securing declarations, regardless of whether the process complied with the law.

He  stressed that  the popular phrase, “Go to court,” had acquired a negative meaning because of public suspicion about the electoral justice system.

He noted that  some politicians used it in a manner suggesting that they already knew the outcome of any legal challenge.

Commenting on INEC’s independence, Osigwe said the process of appointing members of the commission remained a major concern.

While questioning  the use of ad-hoc electoral officers, including academics, alleging that some officials recruited for election duties had later faced criminal proceedings, he stated that voter turnout would continue to decline if Nigerians believed that their votes could be manipulated between polling units and collation centres.

He also criticised the conduct of some State Independent Electoral Commissions, saying ruling parties often recorded overwhelming victories in local government elections, thereby reinforcing the perception that electoral bodies were not independent.

Osigwe linked the crisis to what he described as a failure of leadership, saying the problem extended beyond the presidency and included governors, local government chairmen, political parties and leaders in homes and organisations.

He, therefore , urged editors and journalists to continue scrutinising INEC, the courts and political actors, saying the media had a crucial role in ensuring that votes cast by Nigerians translated into legitimate political mandates.